Before you dive headfirst into new email marketing strategies for 2026, there's one crucial step many businesses skip: looking back at what actually worked (and what didn't) in 2025. An email marketing audit sounds intimidating, but it's really just an organized way to learn from your data so you can make smarter decisions going forward.

The best part? This audit will take you 30-60 minutes and will reveal clear, actionable insights that can immediately improve your results. Let's walk through it step by step.

Step 1: Gather Your Key Metrics

First, you need to pull your performance data. Log into your email marketing platform and export or note these metrics for 2025:

Overall account metrics:

• Total emails sent
• Average open rate
• Average click-through rate
• Average conversion rate (if tracked)
• Unsubscribe rate
• List growth rate
• Bounce rate

Campaign-specific data:

• Your top 10 best-performing emails (by open rate and click rate)
• Your 5 worst-performing emails
• Any emails that generated significant unsubscribes or complaints

Most platforms like Mailchimp, Constant Contact, or HubSpot make this data easy to access in their analytics dashboards. If you're struggling to find these numbers or aren't sure your platform is set up correctly to track them, this is a common issue we address when helping clients set up or optimize their email marketing systems.

Industry benchmarks for comparison:

• Small business average open rate: 21-24%
• Small business average click rate: 2-3%
• Nonprofit average open rate: 25-27%
• Nonprofit average click rate: 2.5-3.5%

Don't panic if you're below these numbers—that's why you're doing this audit.

Step 2: Identify Your Best and Worst Performers

Now comes the detective work. Look at your top 10 and bottom 5 emails and search for patterns.

Questions to ask about your top performers:

• What day and time were they sent?
• What was the subject line style? (Question, statement, emoji, personalized, curiosity-driven?)
• What type of content did they contain? (Story, offer, education, update?)
• How long was the email?
• What was the call-to-action?
• Were they sent to your full list or a specific segment?

Questions to ask about your worst performers:

• Did they have something in common? (Same topic, same format, same send time?)
• Were the subject lines unclear or too salesy?
• Did they go to a tired segment that might need re-engagement or removal?
• Was the timing off? (Sent during holidays, major news events, or busy seasons for your audience?)

Write down 3-5 specific observations. For example: "Emails with question-based subject lines opened 8% better than statements" or "Story-driven content about customer success got 3x more clicks than product-focused emails."

These patterns are gold. They tell you what your specific audience responds to, which is far more valuable than generic best practices.

Step 3: Analyze List Health

A healthy email list is like a healthy garden—it should be growing, but it also needs pruning.

Calculate your list growth rate:

(New subscribers - Unsubscribes) / Total subscribers at start of year × 100

A healthy growth rate for small businesses is 2-5% monthly. For nonprofits with active campaigns, 3-7% monthly is good.

Check engagement trends:

Pull your overall open and click rates by quarter:

• Q1 2025: ___% open, ___% click
• Q2 2025: ___% open, ___% click
• Q3 2025: ___% open, ___% click
• Q4 2025: ___% open, ___% click

Are these trending up, down, or staying steady? A declining trend means you need to focus on list cleaning and re-engagement in 2026 (see our article on 5 Email Marketing Resolutions Every Small Business Should Make in 2026 for strategies to reverse this trend).

Review deliverability issues:

Check your bounce rate (should be under 2%) and spam complaint rate (should be under 0.1%). High numbers here indicate technical issues that need immediate attention. Common culprits include:

• Purchased or scraped email lists (never do this)
• Infrequent sending that makes people forget they subscribed
• Poor list hygiene
• Technical setup issues with your domain authentication

If you're seeing deliverability problems, it's worth having a professional review your email platform setup and domain authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC records). This technical foundation is crucial for getting your emails into inboxes.

Step 4: Review Your Automation Performance

If you set up any automated email sequences in 2025, now's the time to evaluate them.

For each automation, check:

• How many people entered the sequence?
• What's the open rate for each email in the sequence?
• Where are people dropping off?
• What's the overall conversion rate or goal completion?

Let's say your welcome email series has three emails. Email 1 might have a 45% open rate, Email 2 drops to 28%, and Email 3 only gets 15%. This drop-off pattern tells you that either Email 2 isn't compelling enough to keep people engaged, or there's too much time between emails, or the sequence doesn't deliver on what people expected when they signed up.

Common automation issues we see:

• Welcome series that's too promotional too quickly
• Abandoned cart emails that trigger too soon (give people at least 2-4 hours)
• Re-engagement campaigns sent to people who've only been inactive for 30 days (wait longer)
• Sequences with no clear value proposition or next step

If you didn't set up any automations in 2025, that's your biggest opportunity for 2026. Automations like welcome sequences, thank-you series for donors, and cart abandonment emails work 24/7 without manual effort. They're one of the best investments you can make in your email marketing.

Step 5: Assess Goal Achievement

Email marketing should tie directly to your business or nonprofit goals. This is where you connect the dots between email activity and real results.

For small businesses, ask:

• How much revenue came from email campaigns?
• What was the average order value from email traffic vs. other channels?
• How many new customers came through email signup offers?
• Did email help reduce customer service inquiries by providing helpful content?

For nonprofits, ask:

• How much in donations was driven by email campaigns?
• How many volunteers signed up through email calls-to-action?
• Did email attendance at events increase year-over-year?
• What was the donor retention rate for people on your email list vs. not on your list?

Calculate your email marketing ROI:

(Revenue/Value Generated - Email Marketing Costs) / Email Marketing Costs × 100

Your costs should include platform fees, any design tools, and the time spent (calculate this at a reasonable hourly rate). For many small businesses and nonprofits, email delivers ROI of 300-500% or more.

If you're not seeing positive ROI, don't worry—that's exactly why you're doing this audit. The insights from Steps 1-4 will show you where to improve.

Step 6: Create Your Action Plan

Now comes the payoff. Based on everything you've learned, identify 3-5 specific improvements to make in 2026.
Good action items are specific and measurable:

X "Improve open rates"
 "Use question-based subject lines 50% of the time since our data shows they perform 8% better"

X "Send more emails"
 "Establish a bi-weekly send schedule every Tuesday at 10am based on our engagement patterns"

X "Get more subscribers"
 "Add an exit-intent popup to our website offering our most popular resource to grow list by 25%"

Prioritize by impact and effort:

High impact, low effort = Do first (like using your winning subject line patterns)
High impact, high effort = Schedule for Q1-Q2 (like building automation sequences)
Low impact, low effort = Do when you have time
Low impact, high effort = Skip for now

What to STOP doing:

This is just as important as what to start. If certain content types, send times, or formats consistently underperform, stop wasting time on them. For example:

• Stop sending emails on Friday afternoons if they always bomb
• Stop writing 1,000-word emails if your 200-word emails get better engagement
• Stop sending to your entire list if segmented campaigns perform dramatically better

What to START doing:

Based on your audit, you might need to:

• Start cleaning your list quarterly (see Resolution #1 in our 2026 resolutions article)
• Start segmenting your audience for more relevant messaging
• Start automation sequences to nurture subscribers on autopilot
• Start tracking conversions properly so you know what's actually working

What to CONTINUE doing:

Don't forget to acknowledge what's already working! If story-based emails about customer impact are crushing it, double down on those. If your monthly newsletter has loyal readers, keep that going strong.

If you're feeling stuck on any of these action items—whether it's the technical setup, finding time to write consistent newsletters, or integrating everything with your WordPress website—remember that you don't have to figure it all out alone. Sometimes the best investment is getting professional help to implement these improvements properly so you can focus on running your business or nonprofit.

Your Free Email Marketing Audit Checklist

To make this process even easier, here's a downloadable checklist you can follow:

Before You Begin:

• Log into your email marketing platform
• Set aside 45-60 uninterrupted minutes
• Have a notebook or document ready for notes

Step 1: Gather Key Metrics

• Total emails sent in 2025
• Average open rate
• Average click-through rate
• Conversion rate (if applicable)
• List growth rate
• Unsubscribe rate
• Bounce rate
• Top 10 best-performing campaigns
• Bottom 5 worst-performing campaigns

Step 2: Identify Patterns

• Note common elements in top performers (subject lines, content type, send time) 
• Note common issues in bottom performers
• Write down 3-5 key observations

Step 3: Analyze List Health

• Calculate list growth rate
• Compare engagement by quarter
• Check deliverability metrics (bounces, spam complaints)
• Identify any technical issues

Step 4: Review Automations

• List all active automated sequences
• Check completion rates for each
• Identify drop-off points
• Note opportunities for new automations

Step 5: Assess Goal Achievement

• Calculate revenue/value from email
• Calculate email marketing ROI
• Compare email performance to other marketing channels

Step 6: Create Action Plan

• List 3-5 specific improvements to make
• Identify what to STOP doing
• Identify what to START doing
• Identify what to CONTINUE doing
• Prioritize by impact and effort
• Set deadlines for implementation

After Your Audit:

• Schedule time to implement top-priority action items
• Set a reminder to audit again in Q4 2026
• Share relevant insights with your team

Making the Most of Your Audit Results

Completing this audit is a significant accomplishment, but the real value comes from taking action on what you've learned. Here are some final tips:

Schedule implementation time now. Don't let these insights sit in a document gathering dust. Block time on your calendar in the next two weeks to implement at least one high-priority improvement.

Share with your team. If you have staff, volunteers, or contractors involved in your email marketing, share the key findings and get their buy-in on changes.

Revisit quarterly. You don't need to do a full annual audit every three months, but check in on your priority metrics quarterly to make sure you're trending in the right direction.

Celebrate improvements. When you implement a change based on your audit and see results, acknowledge it! This builds momentum and makes it easier to continue optimizing.

Get help when you need it. Some of what you discover might require expertise you don't have in-house. Whether that's technical platform setup, consistent content creation, or website integration, professional support can accelerate your results significantly.

Looking ahead to 2026, your audit has given you a roadmap. You know what worked, what didn't, and what needs to change. Now it's time to put that knowledge into action.

For budget-conscious nonprofits wondering how to implement these improvements without breaking the bank, check out our article on Email Marketing on a Shoestring: Budget-Friendly Strategies for Nonprofits. And if you're ready to set specific goals for the year ahead, our 5 Email Marketing Resolutions Every Small Business Should Make in 2026 article provides a practical framework for steady improvement.

Here's to making 2026 your most successful email marketing year yet—based on data, not guesswork.

   Return